I was asked a few good questions recently and thought those questions with my replies might make an enlightening post for HQ. The questions have been posted without editing or correction.
Preamble: I wanted first off to say that I do respect your positions. I think you are one of the most open-minded people I’ve met (on the internet or other wise).
Thank you.
I want to ask you a few personal questions and if you do not want to answer I understand. These are just some things I cannot experience but want to understand.
Question: I gather from you posts that you are homosexual/gay (I’m not sure what word is politically correct I’ll use gay because to me it sounds cool). Ok enough tip toeing around. There are a few issues that I really want to understand: 1) choice vs. nature; 2) how important gay issues are to you; 3) how hurtful to you is it that certain words like “gay” are used as analogies to “bad”; and 4) does your perspective as a gay man allow you to be more open-minded.
I don’t concern myself too much with political correctness.
“Gay” is just fine.
I don’t believe there’s any choice involved in sexual orientation. In the nature vs. nurture debate, some presume nurture to involve a choice. But if it does, it’s a choice by someone else (i.e. parents), not the choice of the individual. Another thing that might qualify as a choice is whether or not to explore aspects of your personality which are present but unexpressed. In other words, I don’t believe anyone could choose to be gay, but they might choose to explore the gay feelings they have that they’ve been repressing.
That’s what happened to me when I was 22. I knew I was “gay curious” and had noticed gay feelings since I was very young. I just never had the nerve to explore them until I met a very kind and gentle gay man who was willing to answer my questions and let me realize a few of my fantasies. I should add that to be clinically correct, I should call myself bisexual. I’ve had relationships with both men and women. On a scale with heterosexuality as #1 and homosexuality as #10, I’m a #7.
Gay issues are important to me as a liberal humanist. Just like racial and gender issues, gay issues are important to me because they involve human repression and persecution.
“Gay” as a synonym for bad is of little importance. English is a dynamic language, it’s irrational to take offense at the reapplication of a word. Words are tools we use to express thoughts. Sometimes we have to overlook the words used and focus on the thoughts behind the words. That reveals the character of the speaker even more than their choice of words.
No doubt all the aspects of my person have added something to my open-mindedness. My gay attitudes keep me from being blasé about sexual matters. Being left-handed has made me aware of what a right-handed world I live in. It is hard for me to find a conventional belief to hold onto when so much of my being is unconventional.
1) This question has been bothering me since Bill Richardson’s presidency was destroyed because he said being gay is a choice. I was wonder what are you feelings on the issue. Right now I cannot quite understand the difference only because in some way I think the way I am is a choice and part of my nature. I’m not sure if I am not gay or bi because of social constructs or because it is my nature. Although, if it were truly a choice, I am not sure any one would be gay (because of the ridicule that may ensue). However, I would much rather it be a choice but a choice that individuals are free to make. Regardless, the biggest part I want to know is does it matter if it is a choice or not? If it is a choice it should be one anyone is free to have. But I guess if we say that then certain people will condemn it as the wrong choice. Well, I’m lost and I am hoping you can help me answer this question as you have probably thought about it more than I have.
As you may gather from what I’ve said above, the only “choice” involved in homosexuality is whether to come out and be known as a gay person or stay in the closet and deny your nature. Honest straight people know that they never chose to be straight. Sexual orientation is not a matter of choice. Sexual expression is. Someone may be attracted sexually to dogs (orientation) but never act on their impulses (expression). They have the desire but choose not to act on it. Many gay people are like this.
2) I think this is strait forward. I want to know how closely do you identify as a gay compared to other issues in your life? Do you identify so closely because it is an issue that needs to be solved or because there is a genuine community there. I don’t know if you are familiar with Vonnegut’s book Cat’s Cradle but in that book he talks about a “karass” and “granfalloon.” Basically, a “karass” is a community of individuals who’s lives directly effect each other, revolve around the same object, and reach the same conclusion; a “granfallon” is just a false “karass” (e.g. in the book one of the characters gives the example that a “granfallon” is the community formed by alumni from a college or people living in the same town). The question might be unfair but do you feel the gay community is a “karass.” The reason I think this might be an unfair question is because I feel like it is a “karass” and at the same time is not. The gay community has cetain common goal but at the same time they are clearly individuals. At my school right now we have a very big GLBT program and they seem to fight over issues all the time. The in no way seem like an actual community any more than the United States is a community. Granted they unify when a threat is apparent similar to how the United States unifies. So I am unsure how strong the bond is between gay individuals.
Community has value beyond agreement on issues. Sometimes it’s nice just to know you aren’t alone. The gay aspects of my personality come into play fairly often throughout the day. I think my sense of humor owes a lot to my gayness, my feelings of being an outsider to much of society. I frequently act as the stereotypical gay man to break the ice or add punch to a humorous situation. However, I’m not much of a joiner. I’ve spent the better part of 50 years defining myself and getting to know myself. I’m reluctant to subjugate that to group think. Quite often I’ll join a group simply to show solidarity without any intention of joining in the activities of that group. Gays usually feel united by their gayness in larger, non-gay social groups. That’s why there are organizations for gay Christians, gay Republicans, etc.
There’s also the fact that it is an issue that needs to be discussed in the open and in light of recent medical discoveries. Homophobia is usually caused by ignorance (when it’s source isn’t self-loathing). The best cure for ignorance is education. Discussing homosexuality publically provides education and dispels ignorance. For that reason I’d be supportive of gay people even if I was totally straight.
3) Again, this is strait forward. I myself try to avoid such words. I treat the issue like I treat feminist and race issues. I think certain words can be empowering and demeaning at the same time–depending on how you use it. But my question is more how do you as an individual feel when you hear some kid say to his friend “that’s gay” or “stop being gay”?
Again, it doesn’t bother me. I’m far more cautious around a person who talks about “faggots” than I am around a kid who says my opinion is “so gay”. Straights who use “faggot” and “queer” are exposing their intolerance and hostility toward gays. That’s a warning sign any gay should heed and be aware of.
4) To me it seems like being gay may very well open you up. It allows you to better understand that people are different. That things can be looked at from different perspectives and still be right. What do you think?
Absolutely. When you’re different, it’s natural to be more sympathetic to others considered different. It evens helps when entertaining ideas that are different and outside the mainstream. Perhaps that’s why throughout history some of the most creative people have been gay.
When I was assigned to the NSA while in the Army, they made it clear that they weren’t automatically disqualifying anyone just because they were gay or used drugs recreationally. Code breaking is a creative art that requires thinking outside the norm. They knew that creative people included gays and pot smokers. All they required was that whatever your particular “abnormality”, you disclose it fully to your friends and family so that no opportunity for blackmail existed. That was the motivation for my coming out to my family and friends. Everyone already knew I smoked pot.
I want to apologize if anything came off insensitive and for the poor witting. I am not proof reading this because it is a little difficult for me to send this and if I proof read it I am afraid I will change my mind. Also, I happen to be a bad writer an a little drunk (which is no condition to be in while writing such an inquiry). So I am sorry for any difficulty. Also, it might be well to say I am far younger than you and thus will not mind you scolding me nor will I mind you talking down to me in your response. You can also write it as a lecture if you wish or any way you might want.
I actually applaud your desire to satisfy your curiosity first hand instead of settling for second hand information. If I had a question about coding a website, I’d be more inclined to ask someone who has done that very thing rather than read a book (that may have been written by someone with no practical knowledge) or take any old Joe’s opinion on the subject. Further, it does me good to reexamine my attitudes and beliefs now and then. Whenever I’m asked about my orientation I have another reason to reevaluate my thoughts and opinions. I’m glad you asked. I just hope my answers are sufficient. If not, feel free to ask further questions.